EZ Rhino wrote:SickThing wrote:I had to write it twice because my professor knew I could do better (I got a B the first time; after my rewrite, I got---a B+).
What the Smurf? Where did you go to college where an instructor would allow you to submit a paper twice?? Granted, it's not a privilege because you had to do the work twice...but still...
It was an Honors English Literature class at Western Kentucky University that a friend convinced me to take with him. On the first day of class, there were only six students who showed up. I was relieved, thinking that the class would be canceled, but the professor came back from the office and said, "Well, normally they won't let us have classes this small, but since it's an Honors class, I talked them into letting me keep it. And since there are so few of us, we won't have any tests. Instead, your grade will come exclusively from papers." I was screaming inside, and if I could have strangled my friend and not had five witnesses, I would have.
Consequently, every single paper I did that semester landed me with anywhere from a B- to an A-. For each B, he'd give it back and ask me to see him after class. After class, he'd talk to me about how disappointed he was with my paper, and he'd say, "I know you can do better than that. Rewrite it and turn it in next class." And rarely did my grade go from a B-whatever to an A. I ended up with a B in the class, a burning hatred of compare-and-contrast papers (and
Heart and
Apocalypse in particular), and no desire to ever take another Honors class again. Oh, and I never took another class with that friend.

My professor was hung up on hidden meanings and symbolism in literature, specifically phallic and yonic symbols. I thought he was full of it 99% of the time, but he insisted that's what the authors intended when they wrote whatever. I had a discussion about this with Rick McCammon once. He said a lady had written a journal article about all the symbolism related to Edgar Allan Poe that existed in McCammon's
Usher's Passing, which is a followup to Poe's "The Fall of the House of Usher." (You can read the article
here.) He said that almost all of the stuff she pointed out was
not intentional. I wanted to take him with me back to my old professor as proof that he (the professor) was full of it.....
And yes, that was the only college class I ever had that allowed you to re-do assignments to try to bring the grade up. He wanted six A students in his Honors class, but he didn't get it.
Hunter